Thread: Amy's performance
View Single Post
Old 08-03-2007, 12:23 AM   #148 (permalink)
i i e e e
Lubz Emilie Autumn
 
i i e e e's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Inside your mind
Posts: 122
Points: 327.37
Bank: 7,760.84
Total Points: 8,088.20
Donate
i i e e e is just really nicei i e e e is just really nicei i e e e is just really nicei i e e e is just really nicei i e e e is just really nice
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tea Mirrors View Post
I'm going to add my two cents. I'm not looking to spark up any more debate or comments or whatever. I've read the entire thread and pretty much everything has been picked apart and beaten to death.

Anyhoo.

I feel really sad. Amy has never been a very good live performer save for the acoustic versions of songs where her voice definitely soars and sounds absolutely beautiful (but anyone can do acoustic). As a singer myself, it is actually painful to hear Amy just yell instead of sing. This is what she has been doing during concerts since forever. But you know what, this is how she sings on the official tracks as well. She's a pusher when it comes to her voice. That happens to be her style and it's starting to bite her in the ass.

Back to why I feel sad. Amy, by far, has much more talent than a lot of modern day singers. BUT she has no idea how to use it. She could be bloody brilliant and amaze everyone if she just took care of herself and her voice. Sometimes she gets lucky and does beautifully live but this is rare. For Amy it's mostly really fucking bad or just ok. I wish that I could call her up and tell her that her voice is beautiful but she's fucking up badly. And to do this while her name is sort of going downhill....I feel sorry for her. Could be because I'm clinging on to the old Evanescence. I'm almost in denial really LOL.

As is a pattern with Amy, she probably isn't going to just "slow down." She likes to put up an entertaining performance even if it compromises her ability to sing properly. She wont take a break unless her voice is totally shot. I think, though, if she just barely makes it through this tour..she could probably save her voice if she starts to take care of it properly. That is a big IF though.

I just don't understand how someone who claims to be "in it for the music" would be so careless with the music and the number one instrument--her voice.

I feel more of a sadness-esque feeling towards all of this really. It's like I've fallen in love with a voice that no longer exists.
All in all, Amy has just not been taking care of her voice, as you clearly stated in this post. I guess she just really likes putting on a good show, that's nice and all but she doesn't draw the line.

I believe most of us have heard the Lacrymosa performance in Israel and we can all agree she had a horrible night. Instead of screaming her lungs out AND sounding horrible, she could have taken a rest. I'm sure the fans would have been disappointed, but honestly, if you really appreciate the music you would understand that her voice is getting a beating and would just give her a break. I'm not saying that this is the ONLY bad performance, but by far the most publicized.

Hopefully, during her little "break" she'll take some care of her voice.
i i e e e is offline