So, i have another one question... (I request I do not want misunderstanding) :cool:
the last days i've saw live concerts videos 2003-2004. I observed you are directed somewhere when you sing (where?).. You emit so much passion that certain times I believe that you pray, (that is the reason who your voice and verses talk to my soul. i think) … or just play-acting?
Apology that I wasted your time. Thanks for all....

----------------------------------------------------------
And if my eyes stamp for always
Soft earth will cover me
And in the grave of my silence
I will paint Stones and grasses
(Dark Mind)

So, i have another one question... (I request I do not want misunderstanding) :cool:
the last days i've saw live concerts videos 2003-2004. I observed you are directed somewhere when you sing (where?).. You emit so much passion that certain times I believe that you pray, (that is the reason who your voice and verses talk to my soul. i think) … or just play-acting?
Apology that I wasted your time. Thanks for all....

----------------------------------------------------------
And if my eyes stamp for always
Soft earth will cover me
And in the grave of my silence
I will paint Stones and grasses
(Dark Mind)

well im not Amy, but she probably does pray once in a while. not sure if you knew, but she is Christian.. if that is what you're asking.
sorry, but it's a little difficult to understand what your question is. what do you mean whan you say she's directed somewhere?
play-acting? you mean on stage? doubt it. it doesnt take a faculty like yours to notice the passion you speak of. she really threw herself into it when i saw them in Charlotte, which was a big part of why it was such a good show. she really seems to believe in what she sings. sure there might be a degree of crowd pleasing that comes with the territory, but for the most part, i(and i sure most other people on this board) really dont think its just an act.
again, i may have missed what you were really asking, but i hope that helped.

well im not Amy, but she probably does pray once in a while. not sure if you knew, but she is Christian.. if that is what you're asking.
sorry, but it's a little difficult to understand what your question is. what do you mean whan you say she's directed somewhere?
play-acting? you mean on stage


Hi, The Muenks, when i say "she's directed somewhere" i mean When she sing, on stage, I believe that it is addressed, directed,send out, in somebody… and there are songs who i believe, she's pray .... (on stage...)
so, my question is Is truth all these? Or simple make acting (i dont believe that...)??

Are you asking if it's rehearsed? Like, does she practice what she does before she goes on, or does she just do whatever she wants? Or do you mean something like...is she being sincere when she's singing?

I do believe that she is sincere with every note she sings. She puts all the emotion into her singing, emphasizing it with her movement. That, at least, is how I see it. It's a very powerful performance.

Are you asking if it's rehearsed? Like, does she practice what she does before she goes on, or does she just do whatever she wants? Or do you mean something like...is she being sincere when she's singing?




If observations in live, shows so much passion and emotion. She's doesnt sing simply as a common singer but gives in the public something more..
I observed that in her certain songs it is reported in somebody and in other songs are heard as prayer or wish.. I hope to become comprehensible… Thanks!!!
---------------------------------
And if my eyes stamp for always
Soft earth will cover me
And in the grave of my silence
I will paint Stones and grasses
(Dark Mind)

I observed that in her certain songs it is reported in somebody and in other songs are heard as prayer or wish.. I hope to become comprehensible… Thanks!!!

So basically, are you simply asking if Evanescence is a Christian band?

Because if you are, we already know that that isn't the case. However, members of the band are indeed Christian. Members of the band (like John and Rocky) had some influence in the Christian music industry before...which is what influenced Wind-up's decision to push Fallen to those markets.

So basically, are you simply asking if Evanescence is a Christian band?

Because if you are, we already know that that isn't the case. However, members of the band are indeed Christian. Members of the band (like John and Rocky) had some influence in the Christian music industry before...which is what influenced Wind-up's decision to push Fallen to those markets.

NO I DONT ASK THAT......
:confused: why you dont understand what I ask? I understand that the meaning of my question is profound (For me it has big importance ), but what I ask is very simple. :)
That question is only for Amy... not for the members of the band.
-------------------------------------------------------------
And if my eyes stamp for always
Soft earth will cover me
And in the grave of my silence
I will paint Stones and grasses
(Dark Mind)

Beats me if she prays or not but she's just good at singing live (and she did practice at it)..and also, the songs were written from experiences I believe. Not all of them however, since Amy didn't write all the songs on the album.

I just say she has a knack for singing live with passion.

Well, they do omit Hello from the setlist. One has to wonder if that's intentional because of the personal connection in that song or if it has to do with the way it would be performed live.

Well, they do omit Hello from the setlist. One has to wonder if that's intentional because of the personal connection in that song or if it has to do with the way it would be performed live.

mmm... yes i think read the post..
Actually, I am not reported in specific track, for this I speak generally.... for her songs... :cool:
-----------------------------
And if my eyes stamp for always
Soft earth will cover me
And in the grave of my silence
I will paint Stones and grasses
(Dark Mind)

NO I DONT ASK THAT......
:confused: why you dont understand what I ask? I understand that the meaning of my question is profound (For me it has big importance ), but what I ask is very simple. :)
That question is only for Amy... not for the members of the band.


Most wonder what Chris (Cfw828) understood and asked to you.

"Big importance"?
What's the real meaning of the inquiry?
What about the right of privacy?

Just my point of view... nothing else.

NO I DONT ASK THAT......
:confused: why you dont understand what I ask? I understand that the meaning of my question is profound (For me it has big importance ), but what I ask is very simple. :)
That question is only for Amy... not for the members of the band.
-------------------------------------------------------------
And if my eyes stamp for always
Soft earth will cover me
And in the grave of my silence
I will paint Stones and grasses
(Dark Mind)

no offence, but i think the trouble is comming more from your grammer than how profound the question is.

Hi, The Muenks, when i say "she's directed somewhere" i mean When she sing, on stage, I believe that it is addressed, directed,send out, in somebody… and there are songs who i believe, she's pray .... (on stage...)
so, my question is Is truth all these? Or simple make acting (i dont believe that...)??

yes i think i understand. are you asking if she's projecting as though the song itself were a prayer? not that the band is Christian-rock, or that the lyrics have a directly religious nature, but that the lyrics to Amy are more like a prayer than a song because of a personal meaning? or, is it only meant to seem that way?
hope i didnt completely miss your point there. but if that is what youre asking, youre right, shes the only one who could answer that. you might be reading into it a little too much, but i can think of a couple songs where that could actualy be the case. hadnt really though about it before.

no offence, but i think the trouble is comming more from your grammer than how profound the question is.

.
Yes you have right... my english is too bad!!!!! :o

"you might be reading into it a little too much"
I'm trying but i dont have much time...

"but if that is what youre asking, youre right, shes the only one who could answer that"
I hope to answer me Not only in this question but also in previous…

The_Muenks, thanks for the answer.. :)